Advanced Aerodynamics and Hydrodynamics for Powerboats

Performance Boat design and setup secrets for Recreational tunnels, Offshore Cats, Racing tunnels, Fishing/Utility hulls, Vee and Vee-Pad Hulls, Bass Boats
Home     New     About Us     Free Articles     Technical Articles      TBPNews Archives     FREE Downloads     Research     Contact Us
Testimonials      Reviews      Join TBPNews       Advertise       Search       Buy Now          


TBDP©/VBDP© 'Economy Optimization Analysis'
Get complete article by email request:   Share:
   
BREAKTHROUGH!
'Economy Optimization Analysis'
by AR's unique analysis and TBDP©/VBDP© software.


Performance analysis of any hull design can be completed to determine 'Economy' operation settings and performance results.  TBDP©/VBDP© software's 'Optimize=Economy' analysis completes a series of performance checks, to find the lowest Power and the lowest Trim Angle (WAngle) required to satisfy the setup at each velocity step through the operating range. Other performance values are resultant of these settings.

This setting is most often utilized to consider the boat's performance at best fuel economy.

'Optimize=Economy' default analysis examines performance starting at 30% (max) power level, testing up to 100% power level, optimizing for LOWEST Power level and LOWEST trim angle (WAngle) for each Velocity.  User can also set the 'minimum' power level desired for the analysis (10% through 99%).

Optimize=Economy' versus 'Optimize=Angle'

  • Analysis using 'Optimize=Economy' will find (specified) minimum power required using minimum trim angle (WAngle) to satisfy a solution at each velocity.
  • Analysis using 'Optimize=Angle' will use maximum power to find minimum trim angle (WAngle) to satisfy a solution at each velocity.

These options will usually determine similar results at higher velocity range of the hull design.  At lower velocities, since 'Optimize=Economy' will use the minimum power setting possible, then higher trim angles will be required to achieve sufficient lift to balance the design setup.  As a comparison, 'Optimize=Angle' will use maximum (100%) power available, and so lower trim angles will be required for the same design to achieve sufficient lift to balance the design setup.

Some observations 'Optimize=Economy'
In practical operation, a lower trim angle is normally desired.  As boat starts to plane, however, operators may apply less than maximum power, and often a bow high attitude will result if less than full power. With bow high, more power can lower bow down attitude. Operators may find that applying more power allows for a more desirable, lower trim angle.

Here's why....
More power allows a lower trim angle, more visibility, better control - but may be less efficient lift (CLW) and thus, increased required wetted surface (SWet) and wetted length (LWet).  The additional wetted surface results in more drag (DW). Operators will notice that applying lower power settings when starting to plane, can generate sufficient lift, using less wetted surface, even though this lift is at a needed high trim angle.  Applying higher power settings when starting to plane can generate required lift at lower trim angles but needs more wetted surface, thus more drag at the same velocity.

Same hull design/setup at same velocity:



Figure 1- 'Optimize=Economy' - Lower power, higher trim angle


Figure 2- 'Optimize=Angle' - Higher power, lower trim angle


   


1)) 'Optimize=Economy' - Lower power usually means....

  • better fuel economy
  • higher trim angle
  • lower wetted surface
  • lower hydrodynamic drag (DW)
  • more susceptible to porpoising
  • less visibility
  • poor handling

2) 'Optimize=Angle' - more (max) power usually means...

  • lower trim angle
  • lower lift efficiency, CLW
  • higher wetted surface
  • higher DW
  • lower L/D ratio (less efficient fuel economy)
  • better porpoising resistance
  • better visibility
  • better control/handling

Results Comparison Sample...

Economy Power Setting ('Optimize=Economy') demonstrates (red line) use of reduced Power; higher trim angle WAngle; reduced wetted surface SWet; more susceptible to porpoising.

Max Power Setting ('Optimize=Angle') demonstrates (green line) use of Max Power; lower trim angle WAngle; higher wetted surface SWet; less porpoising.


Figure 3- 'Economy Power' Setting versus 'Max Power' Setting - performance graphs for 'Power', 'SWet', 'Trim Angle', 'Porpoising'


Performance Analysis/Optimization Options - TBDP/VBDP can employ 4 different Optimizing methods of performance analysis, each highlighting different performance scenerios  and features. Get full performance data,data points for chosen analysis method:

1) Max Velocity or Test Velocity,
2) Trim Angles with Full Power,
3) Economy analysis with Lowest Power & Lowest Trim Angle,
4) Power Required analysis for specified Trim Angles. [includes acceleration and Elapsed Time]

Each optimizing method presents comprehensive performance results measures through full operating velocity range, detailed hull performance characteristics.

 
 
 
 

 
 

All above research results included in performance analysis software by TBDP©/VBDP©


[more about AR's research     more about AR's publications    and    technical articles/papers]
 

jim2.jpg (37035 bytes)
about Jim Russell

13th edition
"Secrets of Tunnel Boat Design" book
secrets_of_tunnel_boat_desi.gif (53x73 -- 21190 bytes)
 "Secrets of Propeller Design" book!

"TBDP Version 8" Software                     "VBDP Version 8" Software                      "PropWorks2" software


Order with your Shopping Cart
Special pricing updated April 25, 2024
Contact us at:
AeroMarine Research®
67 Highland Crescent, Cambridge, ON, Canada, N1S1M1
Tel: 519-240-7959

©Copyright by AeroMarine Research and Jim Russell, 1999, all rights reserved.
Material from this website may be not copied or used or redistributed, in whole or in part, without specific written consent of Jim Russell or AeroMarine Research®.